Light-sided coastal-traditional home with a raised porch, broad lawn, brick steps and a mature live oak.

Bayline Development in Calabash, NC: What Buyers Should Watch

October 22, 2026

On June 9, the Calabash Board of Commissioners saw the full Bayline development on one page for the first time. The total read 2,476 residential units. According to the Brunswick Beacon, Commissioner Forrest King said, "This is the first time I've seen those two numbers placed together. I thought that there was a reduction in how many units were going in there, and all of a sudden that number has jumped." Several board members had understood the project to be closer to 2,300 homes. The master plan passed 3–2, with King and Commissioner Shaun Bellamy voting no.

That 2,476 figure is the one people repeat. For anyone comparing Calabash with other towns along the state line, it is also the least useful number in the story. It is a ceiling built from paperwork. The figures that will shape what you pay, what you compete with and what you drive through are smaller, more recent and already moving.

How two old approvals became one big number

Bayline is Criteria Development's project on 1,137.62 acres between Old Georgetown Road and Thomasboro Road, just south of U.S. 17. It started in 2021 under two different governments. Most of the land was then in unincorporated Brunswick County, and only a portion was inside Calabash. The town annexed the whole property in 2023 and has been catching up on the administrative work ever since.

Town Planner Kelley Currie walked the board through the arithmetic.

Approval When Units
Brunswick County Planning Board conceptual plan, county portion June 2021 2,159
County plan's estimate for the Calabash portion June 2021 151
Calabash special use permit for land already in town Five months later 317
Total the board had in mind, county figure plus the 151 estimate 2,310
Total now in the master plan, county figure plus the 317 permit 2,476

The 151 was only an estimate on the county's drawing. Once the town approved its own 317, the old estimate stopped mattering, and Currie described it as "irrelevant." Commissioner Michael Herring called the June vote "basically a cleanup of what we had with two different site plans."

The realistic count is lower than either total. The master plan maps eight phases with 1,445 units and leaves 1,031 units unassigned. Currie told the board that Criteria's engineering manager, Micah Jones, had said at the planning board that the company is "probably actually reasonably only going to get about 800 more units out of the project." Town Administrator Michael Price added that engineering, road layouts, open-space rules and wetlands could all hold the final number below the maximum.

What has actually cleared the board

The units that count are the ones with platted lots, and that number has grown steadily since May. Each step below is a preliminary plat approved by the Calabash commissioners:

  1. Phase 5, May 12: 161 cottage and duplex lots on 34.22 acres along Old Georgetown Road, which Criteria principal Marion Uter called "the only townhouse section."
  2. Phase 2, June 9: 171 single-family lots on 66.86 acres, with 30.48 acres of open space.
  3. Phase 1 and the connector road, July 14: 133 detached homes on 48.84 acres, plus Bayline Boulevard. The boulevard is a road of about a mile with signalized intersections, linking Old Georgetown Road and Thomasboro Road.
  4. Phases 4 and 6, Aug. 11: 178 duplex units and 203 single-family homes on 111 acres.
  5. Phase 8, Sept. 15: 128 single-family homes on 41.18 acres, reached from Thomasboro Road.

That makes 974 units across six of the eight outlined phases. As of the Sept. 15 meeting, none had final plat approval. In August, the developer said it was preparing to seek final plat for part of Phase 4 and begin building homes. By then, much of the water and sewer infrastructure was reported in place, with pump-station testing nearly done.

The plats point the same direction as the engineer's estimate. One earlier version of the master plan put 317 multifamily units in Phase 8. The plat that passed has 128 single-family lots. Currie said, "We're kind of doing a lot better at a 128 single-family home density over there." The Phase 8 plat also sets aside 14.39 acres of common area where the town ordinance requires 2.05. Phase by phase, Bayline is coming in less dense than the headline suggests, and it is mostly detached homes.

The town is paying for the growth before the houses arrive

The bill for Bayline shows up in the town budget long before most of the homes do.

In June, the commissioners unanimously adopted a fiscal 2026–27 budget with a 2.8-cent property tax increase. The increase covers debt on a new town hall: a former television and radio recording studio at 8840 Old Georgetown Road, under contract for $3.1 million. That is the same road that will carry one end of Bayline Boulevard. The building has 12,016 square feet on 6.22 acres. The current town hall has 2,671. Price said the planner had moved into a small office that used to be the mayor's, "so the mayor is out of an office now, too."

The state Local Government Commission approved $2 million in financing on July 7. The town is putting in $1.1 million in cash. WECT reported that Price expects the building to "meet our needs for the next 30 to 40 years." Price tied the purchase directly to "our town's ongoing development," and the Beacon noted that Bayline could nearly double the town's population within a decade.

Calabash's rate is still small. The Beacon's preview of the draft budget put the proposed rate at 9.8 cents per $100 of assessed value. That would be the second increase in two years, since the previous budget had also raised the rate by 1.2 cents. On a home assessed at $300,000, the 2.8-cent increase alone adds $84 a year. The amount matters less than the timing. The people who own in Calabash today are paying for a town hall sized for a town that hasn't been built yet.

The next change comes from the county. Brunswick County's 2027 revaluation takes effect Jan. 1, 2027. Its Schedule of Values had a public hearing set for Oct. 19, with the county commissioners scheduled to consider adopting it on Nov. 2. Updated value notices are expected in February or March 2027. The county says the tax effect can't be known until towns adopt their fiscal 2028 rates. For a buyer closing this winter, that means the town rate is set, the assessed value isn't, and the county's revaluation notice is the page to follow.

What this means if you're comparing Calabash right now

Look at the timing. Calabash has committed to growth through its budget and its roads, but Bayline homes from national builders are only starting to come to market. Criteria's builder list includes Lennar, NVR/Ryan Homes, Caviness & Cates, New Leaf Builders and Great Southern Homes. No starting prices or sales dates have been published.

That arrives in a county market that has already slowed. In August 2026, Brunswick County's median sales price was $392,000, unchanged from August 2025. Homes sold fell 8.9%, from 629 to 573, and average time on market rose about a week to 95 days, according to the Brunswick County Association of REALTORS®. Year to date through August, the county median was up 4.2%, to $387,334. These are countywide figures and not Calabash-specific. Still, they describe a market where homes take three months to sell. Hundreds of new detached homes on Thomasboro and Old Georgetown will be added to that, and every one of them is new construction competing with Calabash resale homes.

Traffic is the open question. The Beacon reported that commissioners talked about holding a traffic workshop, with no date set. Herring called the Old Georgetown-to-Thomasboro connector "a huge bonus for our traffic issues." Whether the boulevard opens ahead of the homes or after them will shape daily driving on that side of town more than any unit count.

The waterfront has been changing on its own schedule. Dockside Seafood House on Nance Street closed in April 2025 after 70 years, and Ella's of Calabash on River Road burned in April 2023. In April, the StarNews described a fishing village "busting with new residents" and asked what that does to the identity of the "Seafood Capital of the World." Its photographs from February showed Ella's site still waiting on a possible rebuild. Bayline is inland, between the highway and the old county roads. The town hall move puts Calabash's administrative center out there too.

If you're also looking at towns nearby, our piece on why Shallotte prices are climbing faster than the beach towns follows the same pattern of inland growth one town up the road. Our Calabash neighborhood page covers the rest.

A few quick answers

Is Bayline inside Calabash town limits? Yes. The town annexed the property in 2023. The board later approved a correction that removed conservation-mitigation wetlands from the annexation's legal description.

Will Bayline's streets be public? In Phase 1, the 1.3 miles of streets are planned to be publicly maintained and built to NCDOT residential-subdivision standards.

Is water and sewer in place? In July, Criteria representative Chip Pickard said the county manager had confirmed water and sewer allocation for every phase. By August, much of that infrastructure was reported to be in the ground.

The tax figures above are general information, not tax or financial advice. Please confirm what applies to a specific property with the county tax office or your own tax professional.

If you're choosing between a resale home in Calabash and one of the first new Bayline homes, or trying to work out what the 2027 revaluation could mean for a property you already own, Carrie Gerald and Brittanie Valipour can help you line up the plats, the road schedule and the comparable sales for that address. Contact us and we'll go through it with you.

Work With Us

Make your next move with the confidence of decades of local insight. We focus on clear communication and reliable representation from start to finish.